Warning: "continue" targeting switch is equivalent to "break". Did you mean to use "continue 2"? in /kunden/116716_10965/jakoblog.de/wp/wp-content/plugins/mendeleyplugin/wp-mendeley.php on line 548
persistent « Jakoblog — Das Weblog von Jakob Voß

Persistent Identifiers: Irony of Fate or just absurd?

24. August 2007 um 01:20 4 Kommentare

The report „Implementing Persistent Identifiers: overview of concepts, guidelines and recommendations“ shows you the impracticality of URN and URN:NBN – you do not even have to read any of the 70 report’s pages to find out: If you try the „persistent identifier“ http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:gbv:7-isbn-90-6984-508-3-8 to get the report’s PDF, you get the following message by a resolver at http://resolver.sub.uni-goettingen.de/purl/?isbn-90-6984-508-3:

Unfortunately the URL could not be resolved. None of the underlying local document resolver were able to find a document with the given identifier. Maybe one of the services is down or a document with the number doesn’t exist. As your URL should contain a persistent identifier, please check again later.

I’d call this 404 2.0! Furthermore at http://www.cerl.org/news.htm one of the report’s publisher (CERL) points out to a review of the report at http://www.clir.org/pubs/issues/index.html#found – which gives you the current issue of CLIR issues (printed version’s ISSN 1098-6383 is not mentioned anywhere) instead of http://www.clir.org/pubs/issues/issues55.html#found. If you ask Google for the title you easily find the PDF. If you ask WorldCat for the ISBN 90-6984-508-3 you get a record where you have to click and search a lot to guess which link will bring you to the PDF – but it’s only the unresolvable URN again.

If people are already to dump to use existing identifier systems (URL, ISBN, ISSN) in the right way, I strongly doubt that persistent identifier systems will solve any problem.